Understanding Narrative Transportation Using Manus AI

In my last post I talked about Embracing Narrative Transportation as a way to enhance the impact of your personal stories. And while I enjoy writing articles about storytelling, I’ve also been exploring AI (Artificial Intelligence) as a way to broaden my research capabilities.

I have to say, it’s amazing to watch these Chatbots in action. They are fast, and comprehensive in their reach, but they don’t replace humans as they still don’t have human experiences that we have, but they are able to locate and analyze information faster than any human.

So I decided to see what some of the latest chatbots had to say about the topic of Narrative Transportation with regards to crafting impactful personal stories. In part one, I asked Manus AI what it thought. Below is the prompt that I used, its initial response, and the output it generated. Warning, it’s a long article, but should you have an interest in AI, it’s an interesting read

Prompt:

I’m trying to understand the topic of Narrative Transportation in depth, as it relates to storytelling in general, but more specifically, how we can use Narrative Transportation to create impactful personal narratives.

Response:

I’ll help you understand Narrative Transportation in depth, both in general storytelling and specifically for creating impactful personal narratives. I’ll research this topic thoroughly and provide you with comprehensive information. Let me get started right away./em>

Output:

Here’s what Manus AI had to say:

Understanding Narrative Transportation: Creating Impactful Personal Narratives

Introduction

Narrative transportation is a powerful psychological phenomenon that occurs when individuals become completely immersed in a story. This comprehensive guide explores the concept of narrative transportation, its application in storytelling, and specifically how it can be leveraged to create impactful personal narratives. By understanding the mechanisms of narrative transportation and implementing specific techniques, you can craft personal narratives that deeply engage audiences, foster connections, and potentially transform beliefs and attitudes.

Part I: Understanding Narrative Transportation

The Concept of Narrative Transportation

Narrative transportation refers to the psychological experience of being completely immersed in a story. When a person is transported into a narrative, they become absorbed cognitively, emotionally, and in the imagery of the story, regardless of the medium (print, film, podcasts, video games, etc.).
The concept was first formally defined by Richard Gerrig in his 1993 book “Experiencing Narrative Worlds,” where he used travel as a metaphor for reading. He described it as a state in which the reader—referred to as the traveler—becomes detached from their original reality due to deep engagement with the story.
Melanie Green and Timothy Brock later expanded on this idea, describing narrative transportation as “a distinct mental process, an integrative melding of attention, imagery, and feelings.” They conceptualized it as the experience of being carried away by a narrative.

Key Features of Narrative Transportation

1. Focused attention – Receivers become so focused on the story they do not think about distractions in their environment
2. Emotional Engagement – There is a strong emotional response to the story with empathy for the characters
3. Mental Imagery – Receivers have a mental image of the story in their heads or try to predict what might happen in the future of the story
4. Cognitive Detachment from Reality – Receivers feel like they are really in the story and not in their real-world environment
5. Belief and Attitude Shift – Narrative transportation can influence receivers’ beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors, aligning them with the story’s content
6. Reduced Counterarguing – When transported, the receiver is less likely to challenge the story’s content
7. Long-term Efficacy – The receiver is impacted even after the story ends, affecting long-term behavior and attitude change

Psychological Mechanisms of Narrative Transportation

Reduced Counterarguing

Transporting stories create a more open, accepting mindset for individuals. When readers are transported in an entertaining narrative, they may not want to interrupt their enjoyment to argue with the story. This reduced counterarguing can occur even when the persuasive intent is obvious.

Connections with Characters

Audience members may:

• See themselves in story characters
• Come to see characters as friends
• Admire the characters

Through these connections, audiences may change their attitudes and beliefs to align with those of narrative characters. Identification with and liking of story characters has been shown to increase the adoption of beliefs advocated by the character.

Mental Imagery

The transportation-imagery model highlights the role of visual imagery in transportation-based belief change. The experience of being transported into a story links vivid images with beliefs implied by the story. This connection between images and beliefs may be one basis for the power of narrative persuasion.

Emotional Engagement

Stories are particularly powerful when they evoke strong emotions. The pattern of emotional experience that occurs as readers progress through a story (emotional flow) can help maintain interest, particularly for longer narratives.

Reminding Readers of Personal Experiences

Stories can prompt self-examination and change by reminding readers of experiences in their own lives that relate to those in the narrative. Individuals who are more immersed in a story show greater generalization of the beliefs implied by the story, but additionally, whether the story brings to mind events from the readers’ real lives seems to be important in determining narrative impact.

Factors Affecting Narrative Transportation

Audience Factors:

• World view (e.g., pro-environmental)
• Prior knowledge and experience
• Attitudes and beliefs
• Empathy
• Political ideology
• Religiosity
• Transportability (individual tendency to become immersed)
• Need for affect (enjoyment of emotional experiences)
• Need for cognition (enjoyment of thinking)

Story Factors:

• Fiction vs nonfiction
• First-person vs third-person
• Well-developed characters
• Intent of character
• Personally relevant stories
• Stories that stay engaging
• Coherence and structure
• Emotional intensity
• Suspense and dramatic tension
• Psychological realism
• Cultural appropriateness

Part II: Narrative Transportation in Personal Narratives

Unique Aspects of Personal Narratives

Personal narratives differ from fictional narratives in several key ways when it comes to narrative transportation:

Authenticity and Vulnerability

1. Authenticity as a Bridge: In personal narratives, authenticity serves as a bridge between the storyteller’s world and the audience’s. When authors share their genuine experiences, emotions, and vulnerabilities, they create a unique connection that can be more immediate than in fictional narratives.
2. Vulnerability Creates Intimacy: Personal narratives that expose vulnerability create a level of intimacy that fictional narratives may struggle to achieve. Research by Hagmann et al. (2024) found that “self-revealing personal narratives create vulnerability by exposing the speaker to others’ negative judgment.” This vulnerability signals authenticity and honesty to listeners, increasing trust and connection.
3. Real-life Consequences: Unlike fictional narratives, personal narratives carry real-life consequences for the storyteller, which can heighten the audience’s emotional investment. The willingness to incur potential interpersonal costs through self-disclosure signals that the speaker values honesty.

Identification and Social Identity

1. Shared Experience Identification: In personal narratives, identification often occurs through shared experiences rather than character traits. Research on patient identification in cancer narratives found that shared experiences can create powerful connections regardless of demographic differences.
2. Social Identity Influence: Personal narratives can activate social identities that influence transportation. According to social identity theory, perceived risk to a patient’s identity increases identification with salient social groups who possess a similar identity.
3. Transportability Across Divides: Personal narratives have shown the ability to build trust across ideological divides. Research has found that people judge ideological opponents as more trustworthy when opposing opinions are expressed through a self-revealing personal narrative than through either data or stories about third parties.

Mechanisms of Narrative Transportation in Personal Narratives

Personalization and Intimacy

1. Personalization Effect: Research suggests that personal narratives create a sense of “personalness” that drives effectiveness. Personalness is defined as “the level of intimacy delivered when narrating an experience, or the capability of eliciting a sense of intimacy with the ‘other.'”
2. <Mental Representation: This sense of intimacy motivates engagement with the content and enables the mental representation of the narrative (narrative transportation), consequently increasing the likelihood of accepting the recommendation or message.

Self-Related Control Beliefs

1. Empowerment Through Transportation: Research has found that “narratives in both written text and video form with protagonists displaying high versus low self-efficacy can, at least temporarily, affect recipients’ own self-related control beliefs when they experience strong transportation into the stories.”
2. Mediation Through Transportation and Identification: The effect of narrative manipulation on self-related control beliefs was mediated by experienced transportation and identification, suggesting that personal narratives that facilitate transportation can influence how readers view their own capabilities.

Reduced Counterarguing in Personal Contexts

1. Disarming Effect: Personal narratives may reduce counterarguing more effectively than fictional narratives because questioning someone’s lived experience can seem inappropriate or insensitive.
2. Trust Building: Research has found that “trust does not suffer when explanations grounded in self-revealing personal narratives are augmented with data, suggesting that our results are not driven by quantitative aversion.”

Impact of Personal Narratives

Building Trust and Changing Beliefs

1. Trust Across Differences: Personal narratives have shown the ability to build trust across ideological divides. People are more willing to collaborate with ideological opponents who support their views by embedding data in a self-revealing personal narrative, rather than relying on data-only explanations.
2. Changing Health Behaviors: Research has found that “identification with the main character in the vignettes was a significant predictor of intentions to participate in cancer research, but only when the mediating role of narrative transportation was considered.”
3. Self-Concept Changes: Personal narratives can influence how readers view themselves. Research has demonstrated that stories featuring strong protagonists who display high self-efficacy can increase recipients’ own self-related control beliefs when they are highly transported into the stories.

Profound Connections with Audiences

1. Solace and Belonging: Stories that expose the raw, unfiltered emotions of their creators have the power to resonate with readers in a way that is impossible to replicate. In our own struggles and triumphs, we recognize a reflection of ourselves, and it’s in those moments that we find solace, encouragement, and a sense of belonging.
2. Shared Human Experience: Personal narratives remind us that we are not alone in our experiences. They create a sense of shared humanity that can be particularly powerful for individuals facing challenges or difficult situations.

Part III: Techniques for Creating Impactful Personal Narratives

Structural Techniques

1. Clear Narrative Structure

A well-structured personal narrative guides readers through your emotional journey with ease. The basic structure includes:

• Beginning: Establish your core idea and hook your readers
• Middle: Develop your central idea using descriptive language to define your story, setting, characters, and plot
• End: Summarize lessons learned, relate your core theme back to readers’ lives, and include a call to action

The ABCDE storytelling framework (from Anne Lamott’s book “Bird by Bird”) provides an excellent structure:

• Action: Drop the reader right into the action. No need to “set the scene.”
• Background: Once you have the reader’s attention, tell them why it matters.
• Development: Build the story up. Where is the story going? What’s at risk?
• Climax: This is the tipping point. The “aha!” The “oh no!” The “SURPRISE!”
• Ending: Explain what it was all for. What was the lesson?

2. Start with a Strong Hook

• A surprising statement
• A vivid scene
• A provocative question
• A moment of tension

3. Focus on Transformation

• Who you were before
• The challenge or catalyst for change
• The process of transformation
• Who you became as a result
• What this means for the reader

Emotional Connection Techniques

1. Vulnerability and Authenticity

The most powerful element in a personal narrative is the emotional connection you establish with readers. To create this:

• Be honest and open about how experiences have impacted you
• Include all relevant details, even embarrassing or painful ones
• Share your feelings as well as your pain
• Never be afraid to show vulnerability—this gives readers permission to accept their own
• Write from a foundation of authenticity rather than trying to persuade or sell ideas

2. Descriptive Language and Sensory Details

Use descriptive language to paint a vivid picture in your reader’s mind:

• Help readers visually experience colors and shapes
• Create sensations of temperature, texture, and physical feelings
• Incorporate scents, tastes, and sounds
• Use all five senses to connect with readers’ emotions
• Don’t limit your narrative to a sequence of causes and effects

3. Emotional Flow

The pattern of emotional experience throughout your narrative helps maintain interest:

• Create and then resolve suspense about outcomes
• Include changes in emotional tone across the course of the story
• Balance difficult emotions with moments of insight or relief
• Build emotional intensity toward key realizations
• End with emotional resolution that feels satisfying

Connection with Readers

1. Make the Reader the Main Character

Your story isn’t really about you—the reader is the main character. To achieve this:

• Have clarity around why your personal story is interesting to the READER
• Connect your perspective with universal truths
• Ask yourself: What’s the problem you want the reader to solve?
• Consider: What’s the realization you want the reader to have?
• Focus on: What’s the obstacle you want to help the reader overcome?

2. Identify the Takeaway

The takeaway explains why your story is important and creates a deeper emotional tie with the reader:

• Connect your experience to something bigger
• Identify the universal truth at play
• Clarify what your experience says about you, life, or the world
• Determine if your story is about frustration, injustice, loyalty, hope, etc.
• Make the connection between your story and the message explicit

3. Relevance to Reader’s Life

Make your personal narrative relevant to readers’ lives:

• Give readers a “heads up” so they can avoid pain you experienced
• Provide relief if they’re currently going through a similar experience
• Show how your lessons apply to their situations
• Create points of similarity between your experience and theirs
• Focus on shared human experiences that transcend specific circumstances

Finding Story-Worthy Material

1. Daily Reflection Practice

Use the “Homework for Life” framework (from Matthew Dicks’ book “Storyworthy”):

• Take five minutes daily to reflect on your day
• Ask: If you had to tell a story from today, what would it be?
• Write one sentence about it
• Look for difficult times, moments of growth, and proud or awkward experiences
• Create two columns: date and story

2. Identify Emotional Significance

Pay attention to events that leave a strong impression:

• What moments do you replay in your mind?
• What makes you uncomfortable?
• What reveals your vulnerability?
• What forces you to confess a character flaw?
• What challenges your core beliefs about yourself?

3. Choose Meaningful Experiences

Select experiences that have been transformational:

• Events that caused you to rethink or reconsider your point of view
• Circumstances that resulted in personal or professional growth
• Painful situations that forced you to change your beliefs
• Unique life experiences that taught you important lessons
• Moments where you overcame adversity

Refinement Techniques

1. Editing and Revision

• Edit for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors
• Add any extra details you may have forgotten
• Remove irrelevant information that doesn’t serve the core message
• Ensure transitions between sections are smooth
• Check that your narrative has a clear beginning, middle, and end

2. Seek Feedback

Get perspective from others:

• Ask friends or family members to read your narrative
• Be clear about what kind of feedback you’re looking for
• Listen to their responses without taking criticism personally
• Consider whether readers connect with your story as intended
• Revise based on feedback to improve clarity and impact

3. Maintain an Enjoyable Process

While writing a personal narrative can be emotionally challenging:

• Have fun with the process
• Relax and tell your story naturally
• Remember that the more relaxed you are, the more authentic your narrative will feel
• View the process as potentially therapeutic and liberating
• Recognize that sharing your story can benefit both you and your readers

Part IV: Practical Applications of Personal Narratives

Therapeutic and Personal Growth

Personal narratives can be used for:

• Processing difficult experiences
• Gaining clarity about life events
• Discovering patterns in your behavior or thinking
• Building self-awareness
• Creating meaning from challenging circumstances

Professional and Leadership Contexts

Personal narratives are valuable in:

• Building trust with teams or clients
• Demonstrating values in action
• Illustrating problem-solving approaches
• Creating connection in professional relationships
• Establishing credibility through lived experience

Educational and Inspirational Purposes

Share personal narratives to:

• Teach important life lessons
• Inspire others facing similar challenges
• Provide practical guidance based on experience
• Create empathy for different perspectives
• Motivate positive change in others

Part V: A Framework for Applying Narrative Transportation in Personal Narratives

Step 1: Understand Your Purpose

• What you want to achieve with your story
• Who your audience is
• What change you hope to inspire
• What beliefs or attitudes you want to influence
• What emotional response you want to evoke

Step 2: Select the Right Experience

• Has transformed you in some way
• Contains universal themes or lessons
• Evokes strong emotions
• Demonstrates vulnerability and authenticity
• Has clear stakes and consequences

Step 3: Structure for Maximum Impact

• Begin with a compelling hook
• Establish context and background
• Build tension through challenges and obstacles
• Reach a climactic moment of realization or change
• Resolve with reflection and meaning-making

Step 4: Enhance Transportation Elements

Deliberately incorporate elements that facilitate transportation:

• Rich sensory details to create mental imagery
• Emotional authenticity to create connection
• Vulnerability to build trust
• Universal themes to create relevance
• Transformation to inspire hope

Step 5: Connect to the Reader

Make your narrative relevant by:

• Explicitly stating the takeaway or lesson
• Connecting your experience to broader human experiences
• Addressing how your story might help the reader
• Creating points of similarity between your journey and theirs
• Inviting the reader to reflect on their own experiences

Step 6: Refine and Test

Improve your narrative by:

• Getting feedback from trusted readers
• Assessing whether it creates the intended emotional response
• Checking if the core message is clear
• Ensuring the narrative flows smoothly
• Confirming that it feels authentic and honest

Conclusion

Narrative transportation offers a powerful framework for understanding how stories captivate us and influence our beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors. By applying the principles of narrative transportation to personal narratives, you can create stories that not only engage readers but potentially transform them.

Personal narratives have unique strengths in creating transportation through authenticity, vulnerability, and shared human experience. When crafted with intention and skill, they can build trust, foster connection, and inspire change in ways that other forms of communication cannot.

The techniques outlined in this guide provide practical approaches to enhancing narrative transportation in your personal stories. By focusing on structure, emotional connection, reader relevance, and meaningful content, you can create personal narratives that transport readers into your experiences and leave lasting impressions.

Whether you’re writing for personal growth, professional development, or to inspire others, understanding narrative transportation will help you craft more impactful personal narratives that resonate deeply with your audience.

References

• Gerrig, R. J. (1993). Experiencing narrative worlds: On the psychological activities of reading.
• Green, M. C., & Brock, T. C. (2000). The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives.
• Hagmann, D., Ho, E. H., & Loewenstein, G. (2024). Personal narratives build trust.
• Isberner, M. B., Richter, T., Schreiner, C., Eisenbach, Y., Sommer, C., & Appel, M. (2020). Empowering stories: Transportation into narratives with strong protagonists increases self-related control beliefs.
• Lamott, A. (1994). Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life.
• Neil, J. M., Gough, A., Kee, F., George, T. J., Pufahl, J., & Krieger, J. L. (2020). The influence of patient identification and narrative transportation on intentions to participate in cancer research.
• Strange, J. J., & Leung, C. C. (1999). How anecdotal accounts in news and in fiction can influence judgments of a social problem’s urgency, causes, and cures.
• Valenzuela, A., & Galli, L. (2024). The personalization effect: How personal narratives drive electronic word-of-mouth effectiveness.
• Van Laer, T., De Ruyter, K., Visconti, L. M., & Wetzels, M. (2014). The extended transportation-imagery model: A meta-analysis of the antecedents and consequences of consumers’ narrative transportation.

◆

◆

Subscribe to the newsletter for the latest updates!

Copyright Storytelling with Impact^® – All rights reserved